Blogs

I believed that web development was an art, and I wanted to share others with my creativity and Knowledge.

October 10, 2024

Understanding N+1 Query Problem in PHP and Laravel: Why You Should Avoid It and How to Fix It

Writing PHP frameworks such as CodeIgniter and Laravel, I began as a backend developer, and the efficiency of the database is a primary concern. One of the infamous performance issues that developers normally face in their application is the N+1 query problem. This problem can go unnoticed and gradually reduce your application’s performance which in turn, will affect user experience as the database increases.

In this blog, I will explain what N+1 query problem is, why causes problems for your PHP and Laravel applications, and— most importantly, how to solve it by using better solutions.

What is N+1 Query Problem?

The first process we get in front of is the N + 1 query problem where in an application there is a loop of queries that are fired to the database unnecessarily. Let's break it down step by step:

1. Initial Query (N): This code gets all the items (suppose it is users, products, or orders) from your database.

2. Additional Queries (+1): Each item in that list results in the execution of a new query that will return related data.

This leads to N+1 total queries; N represent the number of items a client wants to select, the 1 is for when a client simply wants to query the database for information. Here’s an example to make it clearer:

In the above scenario:

- The first query (User::all()) fetches all users.

Finally, for each user, a new query to get only the related posts is performed.

If you have 100 users, you are running 1 query to get users and then 100 more queries to get the related posts equaling to 101 queries. This is highly inefficient!

Why is N+1 Query a Problem?

1. Performance Degradation: In the same process, every query accumulates time to the overall response time of the system. Additional queries increase the amount of time the program spends requesting information from the database to display, hence slow performance.

2. Database Overload: When you run too many queries that have no apparent reason, you create pressure on your database server and can easily reach a point whereby your performance is very slow. It could even cause database timeouts or crashes under high loads of traffic to the site, based of course on how congested the database was prior to the Learn More button.

3. Inefficient Resource Utilization: Every query puts a load on the processor and brings the clam for memory. N+1 queries result in extra trips to the server to run the identical sort of query which could have been executed with a single query.

4. Scalability Issues: Unfortunately, as the size of your application increases in terms of users or data quantity, the problem described as N+1 will also increase, amplifying the situation.

Discovering N+1 Queries in Laravel & CodeIgniter

When working with Laravel, the Eloquent ORM tends to lead to the N+1 problem when working with relations between models ( for example hasMany, belongsTo, etc.). It remains possible to familiarize N+1 queries through recursive form using Laravel’s diagnostics including Laravel Telescope and the dd() function to dump frequently database queries.

In CodeIgniter, particularly with the ORM, the two methods will not be possible if you manually perform relations by sending individual queries in the loops.

The N+1 query problem

Fortunately, N+1 queries can be blocked by using even better database querying strategy. Below are some strategies to prevent the issue in PHP, Laravel, and CodeIgniter:

1. Eager Loading in Laravel

Join eager loading is one of the most potent methods of loading relationships in one query. In Laravel instead of making queries for each related record, it is possible to call the main entity with its related ones using JOIN in the single query.

Here’s how you can fix the N+1 problem in Laravel:

This query fetches all the users and their corresponding posts in one query as whether the number of users is ten, hundred, thousand, or a million. The result is an increase in performance to a large extent.

2. Using join() in CodeIgniter

To prevent themselves from happening in CodeIgniter, one can use SQL keyword JOIN to fetch the related data in the same query.

This makes certain that you get the required information without using queries inside a loop, one by one.

3. Batch Queries

It is also possible to make the queries batched. It is far efficient than the standard scenario where a record is fetched at a time, or even several records of one entity at a time; it is possible to batch fetch records belonging to various other entities (related ones) at once. This is where Laravel’s `chunk()` method is useful for it enables you to do just that.

4. Caching Query Results

You can also decrease the amount of work of a database through caching the results of queries. Cache as a feature of Laravel enables storing the results of costly queries and their reuse without adjusting to the database.

Why Eager Loading and Query Optimization?

Using these techniques, you can conceiveably cut down the number of queries that your application sends by a large margin. This leads to:

– It is faster to develop since less time is spent on the application calling databases.

It means less load on the database and that should help to make your application even more scalable.

- Optimized user experience as it enhances pages loading and general performance.

Avoiding N+1 Problems in PHP: The Good and Bad Practices

1. Always inspect your queries: Use debugging tools to check out how many queries are being ran during a request.

2. Use eager loading whenever you are using relationships or Eloquent ORM in Laravel or JOINs in CodeIgniter.

3. Normally, you should improve the way your database is being indexed to enable quick retrieval when running queries.

4. Cache the retrieved data as frequent data lookups will be made.

5. Batch processing should be used for better handling of large data volumes.

Conclusion